What will replace traditional capitalism: Future of the economy P8
What will replace traditional capitalism: Future of the economy P8
A good deal of what you’re about to read will sound impossible given today’s political climate. The reason being that more so than the previous chapters in this Future of the Economy series, this final chapter deals with the unknown, an era in human history that has no precedent, an era many of us will experience in our lifetimes.
This chapter explores how the capitalist system we've all come to depend on will gradually evolve into a new paradigm. We'll talk about the trends that will make this change inevitable. And we'll talk about the higher level of wealth this new system will bring about for mankind.
Accelerated change leads to seismic and global economic instability
But before we delve into this optimistic future, it’s important we understand the gloomy, near future transition period we’ll all live through between 2020 to 2040. To do this, let’s run through an overly condensed recap of what we’ve learned in this series so far.
Over the next 20 years, a considerable percentage of today’s working-age population will head into retirement.
Simultaneously, the market will see significant advances in robotics and artificial intelligence (AI) systems at year-over-year.
This future labor shortage will also contribute to this marching technological development as it will force the market to invest in new, labor-saving technologies and software that will make companies more productive, all while reducing the total number of human workers they need to operate (or more likely, by not hiring new/replacement human workers after existing workers retire).
Once invented, each new version of these labor-saving technologies will filter throughout all industries, displacing millions of workers. And while this technological unemployment isn't anything new, it's the accelerating pace of robotic and AI development that's making this change difficult to adjust to.
Ironically, once enough capital is invested into robotics and AI, we will once again see a surplus of human labor, even while factoring in the smaller size of the working age population. This makes sense given the millions of people technology will force into unemployment and underemployment.
A surplus of human labor in the market means more people will compete for fewer jobs; this makes it easier for employers to suppress pay or freeze salaries. In the past, such conditions would work to also freeze investment into new technologies since cheap human labor used to always be cheaper than expensive to factory machines. But in our brave new world, the rate that robotics and AI are progressing means they will become cheaper and more productive than human workers, even if said humans worked for free.
By the late-2030s, the unemployment and under-employment rates will become chronic. Wages will flatline across industries. And the wealth divide between the rich and poor will grow increasingly severe.
Consumption (spending) will falter. Debt bubbles will burst. Economies will freeze. The electorate will get pissed.
Populism on the rise
In times of economic stress and uncertainty, voters gravitate to strong, persuasive leaders who can promise easy answers and easy solutions to their struggles. While not ideal, history has shown that this is a perfectly natural reaction voters exhibit when they are fearful for their collective future. We'll cover the details of this and other government-related trends in our upcoming Future of the Government series, but for the sake of our discussion here, it’s important to note the following:
By the late-2020s, the Millennials and Generation X will begin replacing the boomer generation en mass at every level of the government, globally—this means taking leadership positions in the public service and taking elected office roles at the municipal, state/provincial, and federal levels.
As explained in our Future of the Human Population series, this political takeover is inevitable purely from a demographic perspective. Born between 1980 and 2000, Millennials are now the largest generation in America and the world, numbering just over 100 million in the US and 1.7 billion globally (2016). And by 2018—when they all reach voting age—they will become a voting block too large to ignore, especially when their votes are combined with the smaller, but still influential Gen X voting block.
More important, studies have shown that both of these generational cohorts are overwhelmingly liberal in their political leanings and both are relatively jaded and skeptical of the current status quo when it comes to how the government and economy is managed.
For the millennials, in particular, their decades-long struggle to attain the same quality of employment and level of wealth as their parents, especially in the face of crushing student loan debt and an unstable economy (2008-9), will gravitate them to enact government laws and initiatives that are more socialist or egalitarian in nature.
Since 2016, we've seen populist leaders already making inroads across South America, Europe, and most recently North America, where (arguably) the two most popular candidates in the 2016 US presidential election—Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders—ran on unabashedly populist platforms, albeit from opposing political aisles. This political trend isn't going anywhere. And since populist leaders naturally gravitate to policies that are ‘popular' with the people, they will inevitably gravitate to policies that involve increased spending on either job creation (infrastructure) or welfare programs or both.
A new New Deal
Okay, so we have a future where populist leaders become regularly elected by an increasingly liberal oriented electorate during a period where technology is progressing so fast that it’s eliminating more jobs/tasks than its creating, and ultimately worsening the divide between the rich and the poor.
If this collection of factors doesn’t result in massive institutional changes to our governmental and economic systems, then frankly, I don’t know what will.
What comes next is a transition into the era of abundance starting around the mid-2040s. This future period spans over a wide swath topics, and it's one that we'll discuss in greater depth in our upcoming Future of the Government and Future of Finance series. But again, in the context of this series, we can say that this new economic era will begin with the introduction of new social welfare initiatives.
By the late 2030s, one of the more likely initiatives that most future governments will enact will be the Universal Basic Income (UBI), a monthly stipend paid to all citizens every month. The amount given will vary from country to country, but will always cover people's basic needs to house and feed themselves. Most governments will give this money away freely, while a few will try to tie it to specific work-related stipulations. Ultimately, the UBI (and the various alternate versions that may compete with it) will create a new base/floor of income for people to live on without the fear of starvation or absolute destitution.
By this point, funding the UBI will be manageable by most developed nations (as discussed in chapter five), even with a surplus to fund a modest UBI in developing nations. This UBI-aid will also be unavoidable since giving this aid will be far cheaper than allowing developing nations to collapse and then having millions of desperate economic refugees flooding across borders into the developed nations—a taste of this was seen during the Syrian migration toward Europe near the start of the Syrian civil war (2011-).
But make no mistake, these new social welfare programs will be income redistribution on a scale not seen since 1950s and 60s—a time when the rich were taxed heavily (70 to 90 per cent), the people are given cheap education and mortgages, and as a result, the middle class was created and the economy grew significantly.
Similarly, these future welfare programs will help recreate a broad middle class by giving everyone enough money to live on and spend each month, enough money to take time off to go back to school and retrain for future jobs, enough money to take on alternative jobs or afford to work reduced hours to care for the young, sick and elderly. These programs will reduce the level of income inequality between men and women, as well as between the rich and poor, as the quality of life everyone enjoys will gradually harmonize. Finally, these programs will re-spark a consumption-based economy where all citizens spend without the fear of ever running out of money (to a point).
In essence, we’ll use socialist policies to tweak capitalism enough to keep its engine humming.
Entering the era of abundance
Since the dawn of modern economics, our system has worked off the reality of constant scarcity of resources. There was never enough goods and services to meet everyone’s needs, so we created an economic system that allows people to efficiently trade the resources they did have for the resources they needed to bring society as close to, but never quite reaching, an abundant state where all needs are met.
However, the revolutions technology and science will provide over the coming decades will for the first time shift us into a branch of economics called post-scarcity economics. This is a hypothetical economy where most goods and services are produced in abundance with minimal human labor needed, thereby making these goods and services available to all citizens for free or very cheap.
Basically, this is the kind of economy that the characters from Star Trek and most other far future sci-fi shows operate within.
So far, very little effort has been made into researching the details of how post-scarcity economics would realistically work. This makes sense given that this type of economy was never possible in the past and will likely continue to be impossible for a few more decades.
Yet assuming that post-scarcity economics becomes commonplace by the early 2050s, there are a number of outcomes that become inevitable:
On a national level, the way we measure economic health will shift from measuring the gross domestic product (GDP) to how efficiently we use energy and resources.
On an individual level, we'll finally have an answer to what happens when wealth becomes free. Basically, when everyone's basic needs are met, financial wealth or the accumulation of money will gradually become devalued within society. In its place, people will define themselves more by what they do than what they have.
Put another way, this means that people will eventually derive self-worth less from how much money they have compared to the next person, and more by what they do or what they are contributing compared to the next person. Accomplishment, not wealth, will be the new prestige among future generations.
In these ways, how we manage our economy and how we manage ourselves will become far more sustainable over time. Whether this will all lead to a new era of peace and happiness for all is hard to say, but we’ll sure get closer to that utopian state than at any point in our collective history.
Future of the economy series
Next scheduled update for this forecast
The following popular and institutional links were referenced for this forecast:
The following Quantumrun links were referenced for this forecast: